Why I think the iPhone 3GS may be retained instead of the iPhone 4

Matthew Panzarino for TheNextWeb

The iPhone ‘next’ would be the flagship, the iPhone 4S would offer Siri and take the place of the 4 in the pricing lineup, and the 3GS would remain ‘free’ on contract. But, if the prices were right, Apple could expand the 3GS from a contract device to an off-contract pre-paid model that might finally give the company a horse in the developing nations race.

The iPhone business is still an evolving one for Apple. It may be their largest money maker already right now but they can still tweak this into something bigger as the prepaid and emerging markets are still a little bit beyond the iPhone.

Apple used to sell one model iPhone, now they sell three, two of which are identical. When Apple introduces the next iPhone, it could drop the 3GS off for being too old or it could decide that having two identical phones is confusing and kill off iPhone 4.

Having the 3GS and 4S alongside the upcoming model makes sense to me because the three models are different enough to be aimed at different market segments, similar to how the iPod line up has different models for different markets and purposes.

The 3GS could be the low cost iPhone primarily aimed at prepaid or emerging markets in which consumers buy phones outright with no carrier subsidies. The phone currently costs around $400-450 outright. If Apple can drop that even further, it would be a boon in emerging markets as well as among the lower income bracket.

The 3GS has allowed Apple to enter the lower price range without having to create another phone specifically for that purpose. Thanks to the decision to include the 3GS in iOS 6 deployment, the phone will remain current at least until 2013. Buyers of the 3GS won’t feel too left out as it will still carry many of the features available to the newer iPhones.

The 3GS may be free with a two year contract in the US, but in markets with no carrier contracts, it’s far from free. If Apple can offer it for $300 or less, it would sway a lot of buyers who may otherwise go for Android, Windows Phone, or even BlackBerry.

The 3GS would still be competitive against the midrange Samsung and HTC phones and the lure of iMessage, Line, and WhatsApp would go some way to keep BlackBerry at bay.

The iPhone 4S essentially is an upgrade to the iPhone 4 so I’d rather see the iPhone 4 killed off than the 3GS. The 4S can be the mid-range phone that offers most of the features in iOS 6, limited in hardware features due to the technical inferiority compared to the upcoming iPhone.

The iPhone 4 of course offers more than the 3GS but why go with 4 when the 4S offers much of the same but better? The 3GS would cost less to manufacture too which means it would be more affordable to consumers. Both 3GS and 4 also do not have Siri. Rather than have a phone that looks similar but has fewer features, might as well go with the one that actually looks different.

These technical barriers are why it makes sense to have the iPhone 4 killed off instead of the 3GS. The 3GS is distinct enough to be a different iPhone yet still offer many of the features in iOS 6. The average consumer would immediately know the difference and understand why certain hardware oriented features like video calling, 3D mapping, built-in turn by turn navigation, and Siri aren’t available on their iPhone.

The 3GS is also less likely to break or shatter when dropped from a height of three feet or so. For a low cost phone, that resilience is more important compared to the more expensive phones since people are more likely to buy cases for those.

On top of that, it’s unlikely for Apple to offer the iPhone 4 outright for $350 or less. And this is probably the biggest reason for Apple to stick with iPhone 3GS instead of iPhone 4.

[Update] Alternatively, what John Gruber said. 3GS goes cheap for markets outside of the USA and iPhone 4 takes 3GS’s place as the “free” phone on US carriers. This might complicate matters a little bit in International markets though.

To be honest, WP8 isn’t a burning ship. It’s more of a ship under construction. I agree about BB10, though. It’s burning badly, even before construction.

In comparison, Android is a huge ship with a large but badly disorganized population. iOS is a ship that’s well polished but keeps shooting torpedoes at the ships around, screaming “YOU COPIED ME!”.

bilalakhtar commenting on The Verge

Review: Samsung Galaxy S III

Of all the phones that I’ve ever had to use, I’ve never had one anywhere near as large as the Samsung Galaxy S III. At 4.8 inches, the S III is the largest phone I’ve ever held in my hand, but it’s also the thinnest. The screen is simply enormous and it is quite a sight to behold. It is also very clear and very sharp. This new flagship phone from Samsung runs Google’s latest version of Android, called Ice Cream Sandwich, and comes in two colors which it calls Marble White and Pebble Blue. It officially retails for Rp 6,999,000 (USD 740).

I hardly ever use the telephone function on these so-called smartphones. As far as I’m concerned, these are data pads, mobile devices that take advantage of the high speed cellular connections for various Internet-reliant apps and services, and for this purpose, the S III simply screams. It’s clearly up there among the best, if not the best Android phone I’ve ever used.

The S III comes with several Samsung-exclusive apps and features including the S Beam, S Memo, S Planner, S Voice, Smart Stay, Direct Call, and an early beta version of Flipboard through the Samsung Store. Owners of the S III are entitled to receive 50GB of Dropbox storage for two years, which is double that of the offering from HTC.

The S Beam allows you to exchange files with other Samsung phones that carry this app by only bumping the phones together over a special wireless network that needs to be activated from the phone. Unfortunately at this moment this means the feature works only among S III phones.

The S Voice is Samsung’s answer to Siri. Voice recognition on this device is pretty decent but you’ll probably still find it faster to just type things out because it would sometimes dictate the words wrong, even if you don’t have a thick accent.

While S Planner and S Memo sound pretty explanatory, Smart Stay is one feature that Samsung seems to be very proud of. It lets the screen to remain bright and active by tracking your eyes through the camera. Unfortunately even though it does have a disclaimer that it needs a bright environment to perform properly, this is one feature that rarely works and therefore falls under the category of plain old gimmick.

Flipboard is an app that has become crucial to my daily routine. If older people are attached to their newspapers, Flipboard is what I read every morning and whenever there’s a free time and to have the app available from the Samsung Store is almost a godsend. To get Flipboard from the Samsung Store you’ll have to sign up for a Samsung account, but it seems that the exclusive period has ended and you can get the app by signing up for a beta program directly through Flipboard’s website.

If you already have a Dropbox account, you won’t need to sign up for a new one as the Dropbox entitlement will simply be added to your account. While the promo says 50GB, it’s actually 48GB on top of the standard free 2GB, so if you sign in to Dropbox from the S III with your existing account, you will have 48GB added to your account. In other words, if you already scored 16GB from the referral scheme, you will now have 64GB of Dropbox storage. Just remember that the extra 48GB will expire after two years.

On the hardware side, the rear camera captures videos at 1080p high definition and photos at eight megapixels, while the front camera produces two megapixel shots and VGA recording. Both cameras take really good photos, especially the rear camera which takes amazingly sharp and detailed photos. Due to the position of the front-facing camera, which is a little bit off center, video calls can look a little bit off in terms of angle. Facial recognition isn’t much to talk about, probably best ignored because it would fail half the time.

The battery on the S III is pretty decent. From a full charge, the phone would last for 10-12 hours with significant Internet use thanks to the 2100mAh battery capacity. If you rely more on WiFi, it would easily last longer. Given the capacity of the phone, I expected more out of it but since the screen is quite large, getting up to 12 hours with my regular usage pattern is perhaps reasonable.

The phone is very thin, quite light, and easy to carry although it feels plasticky and hollow. Somehow this seems to be a trademark of Samsung’s as the Galaxy S, the Galaxy Y, and even the Tab, all have that same feel. 

In short, the Galaxy S III is clearly a phone that’s ahead of the pack. A lot of the Samsung-exclusive apps may be not much more than gimmicks but the device itself does the job very well. It wouldn’t be surprising to see this phone on top of the Android line up, even ahead of the benchmark Galaxy Nexus.

On a personal level, this phone is a bit difficult to use due to its size. Having used to the iPhone’s 3.5-inch screen and the N9’s 3.9-inch screen, going beyond 4 inches posed a lot of typing and usability issues. If you’re the kind of person who would use such a device with two hands, it might not be a problem but for those who are used to using smartphones one handed, anything beyond a 4-inch screen would require some palm acrobatics, or resort to using two hands.

Oh one last thing, the Motion feature set is certainly one that is worth checking out and what is probably my favorite Motion feature of the phone is the screenshot action. On other Samsung phones you press a combination of physical buttons to take a screenshot, but on the S III, you can swipe the side of your palm across the entire screen from one side to the other and it will capture it for you. It can be hit and miss from time to time due to your hand pressing too hard on the screen, but it’s certainly pretty cool.

What Microsoft’s announcement on Monday really boils down to.

Barely Scratching the (Microsoft) Surface

Microsoft announced its own brand of tablets on Monday in Los Angeles. Called the Microsoft Surface, it comes in two variants, one running Windows RT, powered by an ARM processor, another running the full Windows 8 Pro environment with an Intel processor on board. If the name sounds familiar, it’s because Microsoft Surface was a touchscreen table (yes, table) which was released in 2007. The current version of that table has been renamed PixelSense.

How is the Surface different from the iPad? To begin with, it has a built in kickstand, a 10.6 inch high definition screen with a 16:9 widescreen aspect ratio, and has a Windows logo on it (some people might miss this fact, really). It also has a USB and microSD ports as well as digital video connectors. Microsoft showed off the accompanying screen cover which doubles as an integrated keyboard and touchpad as well as a pen for the Pro version. Surface for RT will come in 32 and 64 GB versions while the Pro model gets a 64 and 128 GB options.

With Surface, Microsoft has decided to enter the hardware space for personal computers and compete with its own hardware partners in delivering devices running Windows 8. Previously it was more than happy to deliver just the software while letting partners figure out hardware manufacturing and assembly, but ever since the tablet market ran away without caring about Windows, Microsoft probably felt that it needed to rectify the situation.

Perhaps having seen its partners failing at seizing the tablet market with previous versions of Windows, Microsoft thought it had to show the way, despite Samsung, Lenovo, and Acer, having already shown their versions of the Windows 8 devices.

Nevermind that other competitors to the iPad have essentially failed so far, Microsoft had to give this a chance. In fact, it’s probably a good time for Steve Ballmer and co. to jump in because there hasn’t yet been a strong competitor to the iPad. 

Samsung can boast all it wants as a leading Android tablet brand but its sales figure over one year is easily dwarfed by Apple’s iPad sales in one quarter alone. The PlayBook is the laughing stock of the market, while Amazon’s Kindle Fire and Barnes & Noble Nook aren’t really available globally and they’re positioned more towards the electronic book reader category anyway.

Microsoft claimed that Surface for Windows 8 Pro, which happen to weigh nearly 1kg, will deliver the same performance that is expected out of ultrabooks as it runs off an Intel Core i5 processor. This puts the Pro version in a rather awkward situation. Is it an ultrabook competitor or is it a tablet contender? Will consumers go for the novelty of this new PC or will they go with the safer options? Until the pricing and battery life are revealed, answering these questions is impossible.

Surface for Windows RT on the other hand, is clearly a pure tablet place. Sure, it has the same ports and keyboard options as the Pro model but with the weight at 676 grams and its OS limited to Metro-only apps, this device is squarely positioned in the tablet category. Will it be able to grab market share away from the competitors? It certainly seems that way but as with the Pro version, Microsoft has yet to reveal the pricing nor the battery life.

In addition, tablets tend to come with options for cellular data but this is something that Microsoft did not mention as well. Reports from various market surveys say that an overwhelming majority of tablets are used at home and within range WiFi, at least in the United States, which means a cellular option may not necessarily be that attractive. Will Microsoft make such an option available regardless? We can only wait until it makes a more meaningful announcement.

Everything so far about the Surface seems pretty sweet but it’s difficult to deny the fact that this is all no more than posturing because Microsoft simply felt that it needed to announce products before it’s actually ready to make such an announcement. At the event, none of the invited attendees were given a fair chance to try out the devices. It’s like being shown a gallery of hot racing cars without being able to test drive, or standing in front of a candy shop and not allowed to taste any.

Surely Microsoft will announce the remaining details in the coming months but until then, we can only scratch the Surface (well, not really, the Surface is supposedly scratch proof) and any in depth analysis can only go so far without the full details being made available.

What’s clear from this announcement however, is that Microsoft will now be competing with its partners but whether it’s going to take the Google Nexus approach and make the Surface the flagship devices by which all other Windows 8 devices will be measured against, remains to be seen. 

PIN to shutdown your phone

//platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

A novel idea which is completely implementable as an option for those who wish for more security. Lost two iPhones last year which could have been recovered had this been an option.

//platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

To ask that every piece of modern electronics is designed to allow the tiny fraction of hackers to upgrade is the height of hubris, unreasonable, and a huge imposition on everyone else that has no desire to ever crack the case. All that ‘upgradability’ ends up making the product cost more and be more susceptible to failure. Catering to the fringe is not the way to make good products. Making the best product you can for a low price is the way to make good products, even if it means eliminating upgradability and home repair.

MacBook Pro: The Next Generation

Apple SVP Worldwide Marketing Phil Schiller took to the stage at Worldwide Developer Conference earlier today to introduce the new MacBooks with Intel’s latest processors. The MacBook Air and the MacBook Pro received the usual and expected regular internal upgrades, but Apple’s biggest notebook announcement was the next generation MacBook Pro.

The new MacBook Pro is a 15.4 inch notebook weighing only 4.5 pounds and only 0.71 inch thick. The screen is a retina display with 2880 * 1800 pixels for 220 ppi, roughly double the sharpness of the screens on the MacBook Air and MacBook Pro. 

The next generation MacBook Pro is powered by a 2.3 GHz quad core i7 Intel processor, 8GB of RAM, GeForce GT 650M with 1GB of video RAM, 256 GB of flash storage, upgradable to 768GB. As far as ports are concerned, it has MagSafe 2, HDMI out, USB 2 and USB 3 ports, and two Thunderbolt ports. Firewire 800 and Ethernet ports have been relegated to dongle status. With this update it looks like Apple is quietly discontinuing the 17-inch MacBook Pro.

As expected, there is no longer an optical drive and since this is the next generation MacBook Pro, don’t expect optical drives in future MacBook Pro updates. Apple has been known to keep legacy models though, such as the white MacBook which Apple quietly discontinued earlier this year but it remains to be seen if Apple will keep selling MacBook Pros with optical drive once the next generation model become the standard, and if so, for how long.

To support the new MacBook Pro’s retina display, Apple has updated its built in Mac OS X Lion, the iWork and iLife suites as well as its professional apps. Adobe and AutoDesk are also updating their apps to support the retina display.

This introduction of the new MacBook Pro marks the end of the monstrous 17" model. The next generation MacBook Pro starts from $2199.